Thanksgiving

Description

Painted in a deliberately cartoon-like manner, this bustling scene of women preparing a Thanksgiving feast debuted in the midst of the Great Depression, a time when the themes of a national holiday, rural customs, and family life appealed to struggling Americans. It became the object of national headlines, however, when it was first exhibited at the Art Institute in 1935 and won the prestigious Logan Purchase Prize. Josephine Logan, the donor of the prize, condemned the work’s broad, exaggerated style as too modern, and founded the conservative “Sanity in Art” movement in response. This controversy only brought Illinois-born artist Doris Lee fame, and Thanksgiving has been recognized as one of the most popular views of this American ritual since that time.

Provenance

Doris Lee (1905–1983), c. 1935; sold to the Art Institute of Chicago, 1935.

Thanksgiving

Doris Lee

c. 1935

Accession Number

21727

Medium

Oil on canvas

Dimensions

71.3 × 101.8 cm (28 1/8 × 40 1/8 in.)

Classification

Painting

Museum

The Art Institute of Chicago

Chicago, United States

Credit Line

Mr. and Mrs. Frank G. Logan Purchase Prize Fund

Background & Context

Background Story

Doris Lees Thanksgiving from around 1935 is a buoyant and detailed scene of holiday domesticity that became one of the most popular American paintings of the 1930s, winning the Logan Prize at the Art Institute of Chicago and reproductions of which hung in thousands of American homes. The painting depicts the interior of a rustic kitchen where three generations of women prepare the Thanksgiving feast: a grandmother, mother, and children bustle around a table laden with food, while a dog steals a treat and a figure in the background carries a turkey. Lee paints the scene with a cheerful crudity of style, deliberately simplifying forms and exaggerating gestures for comic effect, in a manner that recalls American folk art while remaining firmly within the tradition of modern figurative painting. Thanksgiving was created during the Depression, when images of domestic abundance and familial warmth carried a particular ideological charge, and Lees painting can be read as both a genuine celebration of American domesticity and a wry commentary on the gap between idealized holiday imagery and the reality of Depression-era life. The paintings immense popularity, which surprised even Lee, suggests that it tapped into a deep cultural need for images of continuity and abundance during a period of scarcity and uncertainty.

Cultural Impact

Thanksgiving is a landmark of American Scene painting that demonstrated the commercial potential of accessible, cheerful genre imagery during the Depression era. Its popularity influenced the direction of American art marketing and helped establish the market for reproductions of contemporary paintings that would grow into a major industry after World War II.

Why It Matters

A beloved Depression-era genre painting by Lee depicting a bustling Thanksgiving kitchen with cheerful folk-art simplicity, capturing American domestic warmth at a moment of national hardship and becoming one of the most reproduced paintings of the 1930s.