Contemporary American Sculpture

Description

In this work, Ben Shahn blended fact and fiction to offer a pointed commentary on the inclusions and exclusions of the art world. This enigmatic composition features eight known sculptures by leading artists of the day that were all displayed at a 1940 exhibition at the Whitney Museum. Three large, unframed painted images on the back walls of the gallery appear to be part of the show, but they were not actual paintings. Instead, they derive from Shahn’s photographs of working-class people around the United States, which he had taken while employed by the federal government as part of the New Deal, an economic program intended to revitalize the economy during the Great Depression. The invented works serve as portals to different worlds. The figures portrayed in them are positioned to see into the gallery but they are excluded from the “real” space of the museum and the modern art on view because of race, class, and geography.

Provenance

The artist, until at least 1945 [Chicago 1945]; with The Downtown Gallery, New York [this and the following, according to Horseman Foundation cataloging record, accessed Jan. 23, 2023, copy in curatorial object file]; sold to Joseph Kaufman (1911–2001), New York, Aug. 1, 1946 [invoice no. 3702, item no. 11, Aug. 1, 1946; copy in curatorial object file]; by descent to his sons, Arthur Kaufman and Marshall Kaufman, 2001 [email from Arthur Kaufman, Dec. 16, 2022, copy in curatorial object file]; sold to private collection, New York, c. 2001 [this and the following, email from Jonathan Boos, Dec. 16, 2022, copy in curatorial object file]; sold to Jonathan and Sheri Boos, Bloomfield, MI, 2014; sold to John and Susan Horseman, St. Louis, MO, 2017; sold to the Art Institute of Chicago, 2023.

Contemporary American Sculpture

Ben Shahn

1940

Accession Number

267240

Medium

Tempera on paper mounted to hardboard

Dimensions

53.2 × 76.5 cm (21 × 30 1/8 in.)

Classification

Painting

Museum

The Art Institute of Chicago

Chicago, United States

Credit Line

Arts of the Americas Discretionary Fund; Wesley M. Dixon Jr., Roger and J. Peter McCormick, Goodman, and Mr. and Mrs. Frederick G. Wacker Jr. endowment funds; through prior gift of Mr. and Mrs. Martin A. Ryerson; Ada Turnbull Hertle, Stan and Polly Stone, Mr. and Mrs. John W. Puth, and Jay W. McGreevy endowment funds; Luella Thomas Fund; Delphine G. Schoen Trust and Dr. Julian Archie endowment funds

Background & Context

Background Story

"Contemporary American Sculpture" is a 1940 tempera on paper mounted to hardboard by Ben Shahn that captures the American Social Realist painter in his most politically engaged and aesthetically ambitious mode, the image showing a scene from the contemporary art world rendered with the same bold colors and graphic clarity that made Shahn's work the definitive visual language of Depression-era activism. The composition is a medium-sized painting—53.2 × 76.5 centimeters—showing a scene of contemporary sculpture with the tempera medium creating a surface of extraordinary brightness and flatness that suggests both the immediacy of the poster and the permanence of the fresco. The tempera on paper mounted to hardboard creates a rigid, durable surface that suggests both the portability of the poster and the monumentality of the mural, the medium perfectly suited to Shahn's combination of activist urgency and aesthetic ambition. The 1940 date places this work in the period of Shahn's most intensive production of social and political paintings, when he was producing the works that established his reputation as the leading Social Realist painter in America. Art historians have connected this painting to the broader tradition of the art-world image in modern art, from the studio scenes of the Impressionists to the gallery paintings of the contemporary period, noting that Shahn's treatment is more focused on the social context and the political meaning, the transformation of artistic practice into social commentary, than the formal analysis or the aesthetic appreciation of these other traditions.

Cultural Impact

This 1940 tempera made contemporary sculpture socially political through medium 53cm bold flat bright poster-fresco clarity and hardboard rigid durability, using Depression-era activist aesthetic to transform art-world practice into social commentary beyond Impressionist studio formal analysis.

Why It Matters

It matters because Shahn painted a sculpture show and made the board feel like it was arguing about what art should do for people—proving that even a gallery could be a courtroom if the tempera was honest enough.