Description
For today's viewers of Thomas Moran’s watercolor, the sight of factory smoke pouring into pristine mountain air might prophesy environmental ruin. Yet within the context of America’s western expansion, the imagery of factories was more ambiguous. Some in Moran's time regarded the factories as a force of destruction, while others interpreted them as symbols of progress. Moran himself viewed Denver’s budding industry with enthusiasm, writing positively to his wife about the city’s growth since he first visited while part of a government survey in 1873. Two decades later, when Moran returned to Denver to paint advertisements for the Santa Fe Railroad, smelting—the extraction of metal from heated rock—had transformed the city into an industrial hub. Although the brooding tone of this watercolor is unlike the artist’s bright, misty-eyed paintings of Edenic splendor, his depiction of the west’s emerging industrial landscape reinforces the same myth of manifest destiny—the belief that settler conquest of Native American lands was inevitable and justified—by illustrating the land’s richness in natural resources. Like the English Romantic painter J. M. W. Turner, whose style he emulated, Moran was primarily interested in the pictorial possibilities of industry. In this impressionistic study, Moran manipulates gray wash and white gouache to capture the vaporous quality of smoke and clouds as the two substances, industrial and natural, dissipate into the yellow atmosphere.
Provenance
(The Milch Galleries, New York, NY, cat no. 53.) (1926-1927); (Biltmore Salon, Los Angeles, CA, January 1927, cat. no. 6, sold.) (1927); Henry A. [1856-1917] and Josephine P. [1866-1938] Everett, Cleveland, OH. (1927?-1938); Bequest of Josephine P. Everett to The Cleveland Museum of Art, Cleveland, OH, for the Dorothy Burnham Everett Memorial Collection. (1938-)
Accession Number
1938.56
Medium
watercolor and gouache
Dimensions
Sheet: 24 x 31.8 cm (9 7/16 x 12 1/2 in.)
Classification
Drawing
Credit Line
Bequest of Mrs. Henry A. Everett for the Dorothy Burnham Everett Memorial Collection
Tags
Drawing Impressionist & Modern (1851–1900) Watercolor Gouache American Color: Yellow
Background & Context
Background Story
Smelting Works at Denver from 1892 is one of Moran's most unusual works: a watercolor and gouache depiction of an industrial landscape rather than the pristine natural scenery that made his reputation. The smelting works—a large industrial complex that processed the mineral ore from Colorado's mines—is rendered with the same attention to atmospheric effects and compositional grandeur that Moran brought to his western landscapes, but the subject is industrial rather than natural. The smoke, the furnaces, and the industrial buildings are treated with the same compositional respect that Moran gave to canyons and geysers.
Cultural Impact
Moran's industrial watercolors are among the most surprising works in his oeuvre because they demonstrate that his compositional skills could be applied to industrial subjects as effectively as to natural scenery. Smelting Works at Denver treats the industrial complex with the same atmospheric grandeur that he brought to Yellowstone, suggesting that Moran saw the drama of industrial transformation as a visual subject comparable to the drama of geological transformation.
Why It Matters
Smelting Works at Denver is Moran applying western grandeur to industrial scenery: the smelting works rendered with the same atmospheric effects and compositional respect that he gave to canyons and geysers. The painting suggests that industrial transformation is a visual subject comparable to geological transformation—both dramatic, both worth painting with the same grandeur.