Description
Here a young man uses a ladder to climb over a garden wall. The sign at his right translates into "School for Young Ladies under the Direction of Mrs. Wachsam"—wachsam being the German word for "watchful." Apparently, overcome by curiosity, the man cannot resist his desire to see the young women concealed behind the wall. Scenes with amorous, sometimes voyeuristic overtones are common in the work of Mongin. The artist also seems fascinated with depicting the exact details of his settings. In 1824, a critic who saw The Curious One wrote that Mongin's paintings are "portraits of houses coated in plaster, garden trees, almost trivial details, and this pleases me greatly. Full of naiveté, this is what I need in a landscape, as in a representation of man's actions." The critic's comments clearly demonstrate his appreciation for Mongin's work, as well as the artist's belief in the inherent relationship between nature and man.
Provenance
Thomas Robinson, Providence.; His sale, New York, Moore's Art Galleries, 16-18 November 1886 (lot 184), Young Ladies' Institute, 17 x 12ž in., as by V. Bertin.; Wendell P. Colton.; Victor D. Spark, New York.; Bought by Mr. and Mrs. Noah L. Butkin, 20 November 1977. Given to the CMA in 1977.
Accession Number
1977.116
Medium
oil on paper mounted to canvas
Dimensions
Unframed: 43.5 x 34.6 cm (17 1/8 x 13 5/8 in.)
Classification
Painting
Credit Line
Gift of Mr. and Mrs. Noah L. Butkin
Tags
Painting Neoclassical & Romantic (1751–1850) Oil Painting Canvas French
Background & Context
Background Story
Antoine Pierre Mongin (1769-1850) was a French painter known for the precisely observed, characterful genre paintings that make him one of the accomplished painters of the French genre tradition. The Curious One from 1823 depicts a curious figure in the precisely observed, characterful manner that distinguishes Mongin's best work from the more general genre painting of his contemporaries. Mongin was known for his precisely observed, characterful depictions of everyday life, and the 1823 date places this in the period when French genre painting was producing some of its most accomplished works, combining precise observation with characterful narrative detail.
Cultural Impact
The Curious One is important in the history of French genre painting because it demonstrates the precisely observed, characterful manner that Mongin brought to genre subjects as one of the accomplished painters of the French genre tradition. Mongin's precisely observed, characterful genre paintings—combining precise observation with the characterful narrative detail that is his most distinctive contribution—represent one of the accomplished traditions in French genre painting, and the 1823 painting shows this tradition at its most precisely observed and characterful.
Why It Matters
The Curious One is Mongin's precisely observed French genre painting: a curious figure rendered in the characterful manner of one of the accomplished painters of the French genre tradition. The 1823 painting shows the combination of precise observation with characterful narrative detail that makes French genre painting one of the accomplished traditions.