John Barnard (died 1784), London, inscribed (Lugt 1419), verso, upper right, in pen and brown ink. Edward Rudge (1763-1846), Evesham [according to inscription and see Lugt 900]. Pierre Remy (active second half 18th century), Paris, inscribed (Lugt 2173), verso, lower center, in pen and brown ink. purchased from (C.G. Boerner, Inc., Düsseldorf).