Description
This drawing is a rare study relating to Ernest Meissonier's never-realized mural for the Pantheon in Paris. After seeking and receiving the commission in 1874, Meisonnier procrastinated on the project for many years. Here, the French heroine Joan of Arc appears at center, without a helmet, on a bare white horse, staring ahead with steadfast calm. The figure of Joan in this drawing appears to correspond to the subject in a now-lost design for the complete painting, which Meissonier presented in 1889.
Provenance
Estate of the artist (1891-1893); (his studio sale, Galerie Georges Petit, Paris, May 18-20, 1893, no. 464) (1893); Alfred Hartmann, Mulhouse (after 1893-1899); (his sale, Hôtel Drouot, Paris, April 12-15, 1899, no. 92) (1899); (sale, Sotheby-Parke-Bernet, New York, October 3, 1975, no. 169, sold to Muriel Butkin, Shaker Heights, OH) (1975); Muriel Butkin [1916-2008], Shaker Heights, OH, by bequest to the Cleveland Museum of Art, Cleveland, OH (1975-2008); Cleveland Museum of Art, Cleveland, OH (2008-)
Accession Number
2008.358
Medium
graphite, red chalk, colored washes, and black and white gouache
Dimensions
Sheet: 18.8 x 30.3 cm (7 3/8 x 11 15/16 in.)
Classification
Drawing
Credit Line
Bequest of Muriel Butkin
Tags
Drawing Impressionist & Modern (1851–1900) Graphite & Pencil Gouache French
Background & Context
Background Story
Joan of Arc, from near the end of Meissonier's life (he died in 1891), is a study for a larger work rendered in the most ambitious combination of drawing media in his surviving output: graphite, red chalk, colored washes, and both black and white gouache. The multiple media allow Meissonier to achieve the tonal range and color effects of a painting within the format of a drawing, producing a work that occupies a middle ground between drawing and painting. Joan of Arc was a subject of particular significance in late 19th-century France, where her cult had been revived by the nationalist and religious movements that sought to restore France's identity after the defeat of 1870-71.
Cultural Impact
The Joan of Arc cult reached its peak in the decades following the Franco-Prussian War and the Paris Commune, when France needed a national hero who combined military courage with religious conviction. Meissonier's drawing participates in this cult, depicting Joan at the moment of her divine mission — the subject that most French artists preferred because it emphasized her spiritual authority rather than her military defeat and execution.
Why It Matters
Joan of Arc is Meissonier's most ambitious drawing and his most patriotic subject: a national hero rendered with every medium at his disposal. The combination of graphite, red chalk, colored washes, and gouache produces an image that is halfway between drawing and painting — appropriate for a subject that is halfway between history and myth.