Description
This unfinished sketch is a study for Isidore Pils's painting Soldiers Distributing Bread to the Poor, which was inspired by an actual scene he witnessed in the center of Paris. Here the artist focused his attention on the youth's upper body and left the legs lightly sketched in, indicating that he must have executed the sketch after he had already worked out the larger composition (where the legs are obscured by a low wall).
Provenance
Estate of the artist (Lugt 2030, lower right, in purple ink); [Hôtel Drouot, Paris (20 March 1876), 32, no. 297]. [Galerie Jacques Fischer-Chantal Kiener, Paris]. [Shepherd Gallery, New York]; purchased in 1977.
Young Man Leaning Forward with Outstretched Arms (Study for Soldiers Distributing Bread to the Poor)
c. 1851
Accession Number
2008.361
Medium
oil, brown oil wash or ink wash, and black crayon
Dimensions
Sheet: 33.8 x 26.9 cm (13 5/16 x 10 9/16 in.)
Classification
Drawing
Credit Line
Bequest of Muriel Butkin
Tags
Drawing Neoclassical & Romantic (1751–1850) Oil Painting Ink French
Background & Context
Background Story
Young Man Leaning Forward with Outstretched Arms is a preparatory study for Pils's painting Soldiers Distributing Bread to the Poor, depicting a figure whose dynamic pose—leaning forward with outstretched arms—is being worked out through the combination of oil, wash, and black crayon that Pils used for his most elaborate preparatory studies. The study demonstrates the importance of figure drawing in 19th-century academic practice: before composing a multi-figure narrative painting, the artist had to work out each figure's pose individually, and studies like this one show the careful preparation that underlay even the most apparently effortless compositions.
Cultural Impact
Pils's preparatory studies demonstrate the working methods of 19th-century academic painting at their most systematic. The combination of oil, brown wash, and black crayon shows Pils building up the figure in successive layers—first the outline in crayon, then the tonal values in wash, then the color notes in oil—before committing to the finished painting. The study for Soldiers Distributing Bread to the Poor reveals the careful preparation that went into what appears to be a spontaneous gesture in the finished work.
Why It Matters
Young Man Leaning Forward is Pils's academic preparation in action: oil, wash, and crayon building up a figure in successive layers before the finished painting, revealing the careful preparation that underlay the apparently effortless compositions of 19th-century academic painting. The study for a charitable subject—soldiers distributing bread to the poor—shows that even compassion required preparation.