Description
Antoine, Louis, and Mathieu Le Nain were brothers who ran a collective studio in Paris from around 1630 until 1648, when Antoine and Louis died. Mathieu continued to produce work under their name "Le Nain" throughout the 1650s. Of the museum's four paintings that have been called "Le Nain" (1958.174, 1958.175.1, 1958.175.2), this work has held its attribution to Mathieu the longest. With his back to the viewer, a musician sits in shadow while a group of children pose patiently in a chain-like formation, awaiting the start of their dance. Because of its reliance on order and collaboration, dancing symbolized familial harmony. The attention to the individuality of the children suggest a family portrait, while their wistful expressions and melancholic tone have led to the hypothesis that the children are portraits-both living and posthumous. The description of the intricate lace and the wearied expressions of the slim boys is characteristic of Mathieu's handling. However, the canvas has been attributed to one of Mathieu's followers, the Master of the Games, because of the static, brightly lit figures whose elongated shadows don't quite describe their forms.
Provenance
Count Ottone Ponte di Scarnafigi of Sardinia (died 1788);; Count Louis de Seyssel, Turin, sold to Salmon P. Halle, 1916; Salmon P. Halle, upon his death, by inheritance to his wife.; Mrs. Salmon P. Halle, by gift to the Cleveland Museum of Art, 1957.
Accession Number
1957.489
Medium
oil on canvas
Dimensions
Framed: 115 x 146 x 9.5 cm (45 1/4 x 57 1/2 x 3 3/4 in.); Unframed: 92 x 120.2 cm (36 1/4 x 47 5/16 in.)
Classification
Painting
Credit Line
Gift of Mrs. Salmon P. Halle in memory of Salmon Portland Halle
Tags
Painting Baroque (1600–1750) Oil Painting Canvas French Color: Orange Color: Brown Color: Gray
Background & Context
Background Story
The Le Nain brothers—Antoine (c. 1588-1648), Louis (c. 1593-1648), and Mathieu (c. 1607-1677)—were French painters whose collaborative practice has made individual attribution one of the most difficult problems in 17th-century art history. Children Dancing from around 1650 depicts peasant children in a spontaneous dance, rendered with the sympathetic observation and restrained color that distinguish the best Le Nain peasant paintings. The c. 1650 date and the subject—a casual scene of peasant children at play—suggest the hand of Louis Le Nain, who is generally credited with the most sympathetic and intimate of the brothers' peasant scenes.
Cultural Impact
The Le Nain brothers' peasant paintings are among the most sympathetic representations of rural life in 17th-century European art. Where Dutch genre painters like Adriaen van Ostade depicted peasant life with comic exaggeration, the Le Nain brothers depicted it with dignity and restraint. Children Dancing exemplifies this approach: the peasant children are neither idealized nor caricatured, but observed with the sympathy and respect that distinguish the brothers' best work from the conventions of peasant genre.
Why It Matters
Children Dancing is the Le Nain brothers at their most sympathetic: peasant children observed with dignity and restraint, neither idealized nor caricatured but simply seen. The painting exemplifies the approach that distinguishes French peasant genre from its Dutch counterpart—the same subjects, treated with more respect and less comedy.